Should Consensual be packaged with 5.0.9?

Main reason I think it's dangerous is that (even without adjusting any settings) it generates inflated percentage grades compared to Default, and you're stuck with those fake inflated scores in your stats.xml

Default scoring is ITG dance points, without the penalty for hitting mines, because mines are stupid. If you want default's scoring values, spend 2 minutes in the menu.
1. When a toasty should activate, all judgements become Miss for several seconds for no apparent reason, except that they apparently don't count as Misses on the results screen?
That is the toasty. It has subtlety instead of the common noisy interruption most themes use. I figured most people would be intelligent enough to figure it out and not report it as a bug. Nobody figures it out without an explanation.
2. Graphics are either actually glitchy or lame kitchy "look what a leet haxor I am" fake glitchy
Graphics are literally the stupidest thing to judge a theme by. If graphics are what you care about, you deserve broken shit. And if you're using the d3d renderer, that's probably causing a bunch of graphical problems because it's unmaintained shit.
4. no Screen Filter option = unusable theme
It's right there on the Player Options screen: Decorations -> Gameplay Colors -> Filter
So you can pick whatever color you feel like. Or you could turn your bg brightness down to something like 20% so you don't need a screen filter. This isn't DDR, you can actually control the bg brightness.
6. Weird white horizontal bar across the screen during gameplay that doesn't seem to do anything.
No idea what you're talking about.
7. Song sorting is really spergy
No idea what you're talking about. It works perfectly and makes it actually possible to find a song in the title sort (one example) without wading through the thousand other songs that start with the same letter.
If you had a substantial song collection and tried to find something in the middle of the T section in any other theme, you'd be scrolling for a solid minute to get there. That's intolerable.
10. If you leave it alone for a few seconds it pops up a screen with stupid-high amounts of unhelpful gibberish
Oh, I see the problem, you failed every reading comprehension test in school. It's telling you the buttons to do different things, as any literate person can figure out.
I bet you're MinaciousGrace or some other FFR/3.95 user.

All in all, a stellar example of someone reviewing poorly and not seeing obvious options.

[snip]

sick burns bro

you might want to try filing bugs, though, although everything you've mentioned is configurable or due to you using d3d instead of opengl (which is poorly supported)

damn that's one of the edgiest posts I've read in a long ass time

hope you got extra cool teen swag points for the making fun of autism joke that was totally needed and not in poor taste at all