First impressions for the foam pads:
The material of the bottom is different than the soft ones, and it seemed to actually want to slip slightly more (oddly enough). I played G2 from Ultramix 2 (10) on it and it only moved about two inches, so I don't think it's an actual issue. The foam is definitely higher density than whatever my old foam pads were using, and I didn't feel like I was sinking into them or anything. The buttons responded well and I didn't encounter any stickiness to them that wasn't attributed to my own feet being where they shouldn't, and I was able to get decent scores on easy songs and passes on things up to 10 - it's really difficult to hit triplets and runs on them that are increasingly common as the difficulty goes up, so I'd say for practicality you should stay below 10s (except maybe easy ones, like G2). Neither of the pads had any issue whatsoever with dropping holds or missing steps, but they are very sensitive so you need to lift your foot almost completely off the panel for it to stop registering (this is what makes triplets/etc so hard).
I felt comfortable with 8s and 9s on these ones, but go for a metal pad if you will be consistently playing 9 and up. I didn't have any technical issues with any of these pads whatsoever, although I should set up auto mapping in StepMania for these for one of the next releases.
EDIT: Actually, I've been getting similar amounts of slip in a bunch of things. Other than that, they're all around better, though.
EDIT 2: Also, I believe my old foam pads were DDRGame ones, the foam in these is significantly better than those were back when I had them (but maybe they changed the design over the years).
EDIT 3: 11s are hopeless unless you've got something to use as a bar.
EDIT 4: Note that they do need some break in rounds before they stop sticking, so the surface is flat like it should be or something like that.
Last edited: 1 February 2014 6:09pm